Butler is nice, as is Quicksilver. In my experience, QS crashed on me more than Butler has, and was a little slower. I prefer Butler, but both are great tools and kick the crap out of Spotlight.
Thanks for the review Chris. I've been struggling with iMovie because it seems to "almost" do everything I need, but nothing quite right. I will be getting FCE this year, hopefully soon.
Nice to see a real price comparison. I think the Dell can probably be found much cheaper with the use of deals and/or coupons, as well.
However, as you mentioned, you didn't factor in the software or the OS. Not only is the Mac cheaper, but it also is far superior just in the fact that not only can it run Windows, but it comes with iLife and OS X. To me, that's worth quite a bit as well!
Nice work.
Personally, I think antivirus software is the biggest scam around. If you're relatively smart and secure with what you download and open on your computer (Mac or other), and if you're running through a router or firewall, chances are nothing's ever going to happen. Pair that with incremental backups, and I'm pretty confident in my setup, and I have both a XP machine and a Mac. Neither is running antivirus.
If I do end up being stupid, and getting a virus on my machine, I may lose a few days' worth of data, but probably nothing terribly important (since I backup after I do anything of major importance).
Antivirus software and it's damn renewing subscriptions is a ripoff - instead, why not just be SMART about what you do on your comptuer, for FREE!
In response to WMD...
While you may find Yojimbo useful with .Mac, what about those of us without .Mac. I personally find .Mac a complete ripoff. It's a slow and tedious system that I have little use for. If you are worried about security, you could always use something separate from Backpack to maintain your keys, etc. Like a database or password keeper on a jump drive or something. I use KeePass on my jump drive. Portable Apps rock.
You guys (Ben and Beeb) have entirely too much time on your hands to post a dozen times back and forth arguing about something that has and will be argued about entirely too long. I wish I had that much free time.
I'm with you Luke - I've never owned an iPod, but have been looking at minis for a while. I'm not big on the nano or the new iPod thanks to it's easily scratched surfaces (I'm not big on cases or sleeves). The silver mini was exactly what I wanted, and now I have to find it used or refurbed.
I'm with you here. I'd love to catalog all my photos with more descriptions or at least a title, but having to open each one up in the fashion required is a bit of a pain.
I truly prefer Picasa on Windows to iPhoto. I wish Google would release Picasa for Mac!
An Introduction to Quicksilver
Final Cut Express HD v3.5
Review: iFrogz Custom iPod Cases
Is the New Mac Pro Really Cheaper than a Dell?
Apple Matters' Reader Profile: Beeblebrox
Best Open Source Software for the Macintosh
Apple Unveils New MacBook Featuring Intel Core Duo Processors
Do Macs Need to Run Extra Antivirus Software?
Productivity Was Never This Unproductive: A Review of Yojimbo
Developer Review: Stunt Software
Travel Light. And Take Your Mac.
Travel Light. And Take Your Mac.
Music in Black & White
Pages: A Dusty Diamond
How up to date is you iPhoto library?